Monster Nutter Butters

These Monster Nutter Butters are almost too cute to eat! Covered in colorful candy melts and decorated with candy eyeballs and spooky sprinkles, these Halloween treats transform simple peanut butter cookies into playful little monsters that kids absolutely love.

They’re the perfect no-bake dessert for Halloween parties, classroom celebrations, or a fun afternoon activity with the family. With only a few ingredients and minimal prep, Monster Nutter Butters deliver maximum Halloween fun with very little effort.

How to make Easy Monster Nutter Butters

Makes approximately 6 servings

Equipment Needed

Small heat safe bowl, spoon, measuring cups and spoons, parchment paper, baking sheet or tray

Ingredients

• 6 Nutter Butter cookies
• ⅓ cup light green candy melts
• 1-2 tbsp Eye of Newt sprinkles mix

Step-by-Step Process

1. Line a baking sheet or tray with parchment paper.

2. Add the candy melts to a small microwave-safe bowl and heat in 30-second intervals, stirring between each heat session, until fully melted.

3. Dip half of each cookie into the melted candy, then set on the parchment paper.

4. Top with sprinkles right away. I arranged 2-3 eyeballs first, then the sprinkles.

Helpful Tips for the Best Monster Nutter Butters

• Melt candy slowly for Monster Nutter Butters: Creates a smooth coating.
• Add decorations immediately: Helps sprinkles stick before the candy sets.
• Use multiple candy eyes: Gives Monster Nutter Butters extra personality.
• Line your tray with parchment paper: Makes cleanup easy.
• Allow Monster Nutter Butters to fully set: Prevents smudging when serving.